The Law Forums will be shutting down on June 30, 2017. We encourage you to resolve any outstanding discussions prior to that time. If you have any questions about this change, please email

CLASS ACTION sue a big corp in AZ because discrimination

Previous | Next
 rated by 0 users
Latest post Mon, Jun 13 2016 10:33 AM by Taxagent. 1 replies.
  • Sat, Jun 11 2016 6:59 PM

    CLASS ACTION sue a big corp in AZ because discrimination

    I was terminated by the big corporation Freeport Copper & Gold in AZ. I am a foreign engineer who started working for the company three years ago by working visa. My offer was a full time position. My performance was excellent every year. But since August 2015, the company has announced to downsize because losing money, HR told me not to renew my visa as pretext reason bad performance and ask me leave soon, and then my position was replaced by an American engineer. After I left, I heard that the company paid the severance package three month salary and benefits to the American workers who laid off.

    I thought I was discriminated by the company, because, first, the real reason not to renew my visa was the company downsizing, but the company paid the severance package to the American workers, the foreign workers just left no severance package. Second, my full time position was replaced by an American.

    So I opened a file in EEOC, but EEOC just issued a right to sue for me. Now I am preparing for a legal war, how much chance I can win? How to find a good lawyer?

    I also think a CLASS ACTION because other H1B foreign engineers also cut by not renewing visa and without severance package. See the link below:


  • Mon, Jun 13 2016 10:33 AM In reply to

    Re: CLASS ACTION sue a big corp in AZ because discrimination

    The vast majority of EEOC complaints end with a right to sue letter. The EEOC takes on only a very few cases to litigate itself on behalf of employees. Look for lawyers who concentrate their practice in litigating employment discrimination cases.

    Federal law prohibits discrimination based on citizenship. As the company was losing money, needed to downsize, and laid off both citizens and noncitizens alike in the layoff, you'll likely have an extremely hard time making a case that you were fired illegally because of your citizenship.

    As for the severance packages, whether you have a good case for illegal discrimination depends on the details of why the American employees got the severance and they did not. Did the company offer any explanation for that? Were the American employees in different positions, or were they union members and the foreign workers were not, or was there some other difference in their status that might explain the differing severence treatment? Those kinds of details are important.

    You should also be prepared for one other hurdle. Your case would likely get tried to a jury. Many Americans resent foreigners taking jobs in this country believing that it takes away jobs from Americans, and given the difficult employment situation for a number of Americans after 2008 that resentment is still pretty acute among a number of people. So the jury is likely to start out without a lot of sympathy for foreign workers. You'd need to overcome any resentment of foreign workers to get the jury on your side.

    Whether the case might proceed as a class action depends on whether all the foreign workers are similarly situated (which they may be with respect to the severence issue) and how many of them there are. How many foreign workers were laid off without severance? If there were just a handful then it would likely not be big enough for a class action, though the employees might still be able to jointly sue the employer. This is something to discuss with the lawyers you contact.

Page 1 of 1 (2 items) | RSS

My Community

Community Membership Search Community